|
Home Tailbox Photos Carbon Fork M5 Carbon Links Frame Concept Custom Bike Custom 2 Custom 3 Custom 4 Custom 5 Final Pictures VK1 - A VK1 - B VK1 Built Up VK2 XPORT CLR XPORT 2 XPORT 3 XPORT 4 I'm Back! My Benz VKHi
| |
|
March 19, 2007 |
|
I have been
watching the high racer phenomenon for a good while. Looking at the success
of the Bacchetta group on major circuits, I concluded there must be
something there. I saw the new Velokraft VKHi and decided to give it a
try. What in fact instigated this decision is that my beloved Baron Clone
was showing some signs of premature fractures, so I needed a back up to my
current main bike the XPort. After some tens of thousands of miles, it was
showing its age. More on this towards the end of this session! Dana
Lieberman at Bent-Up Cycles set me up with a frame kit. As you will see, I
went through 2 versions of this bike, the first set up as it was intended
with a 650 front wheel, and the second with a 20 inch (406) front. The
reason was that after most of my cycling life spent on a low racer, I am not
sure I can get used to a high racer.
Getting back
to my pre bypass surgery cycling level has not been easy. Previously I was
always able to hang with my group without too much trouble in the 23-26 MPH
range. Now, I am finding that 22 is about as fast as I want to go, perhaps
it is because I don’t really want to try. My recovery heart rate is not as
rapid as it used to be, but I am not worried as all tests are quite normal
and the docs are very pleased. Guess I have to blame it on old age. Added
to that, I am still here which is more important! |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
I bought the
frame from Dana complete with the VK flip-up tiller and handlebar, carbon
seat and the TerraCycle over/under idler with titanium cog. More on this
later! The quality of this VK product is very high. I had two other VK
products, and Kamil’s (Velokraft) workmanship has greatly improved. The
finish is very glossy and deep and is heads up better than his early bikes.
As for components, I had two 650 Spinergy X-Lite carbon wheels and a carbon
fork. I also fitted it with my Rotor Cranks which I took off of my Baron
Clone. I used SRAM twist shifters and a mid quality Shimano brake in the
rear and a Bacchetta pull down in the front. The geometry was almost equal
to my BC and my XPort shown here. On the VKHi the seat/BB difference is a
bit over 6 inches, whereas on my lowracers it was over 7 inches. The seat
height, however, on the VK was about 5 inches higher. Initially this took
some to get used to, and is what made me consider a smaller front wheel.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
The first PICS
show the VK flip-Up tiller with handlebars. A truly beautiful piece of
engineering! Super light and perfect fit on the steerer tube. Having said
all that, it did not work for me. I am a stickler for stiffness! I tend to
be a masher on the cranks (as opposed to spinning) and when I am mashing I
am also pulling on the bars. This set up proved to be much too elastic for
me. I did not feel comfortable with the amount of “give” in the system. I
also did not need the flip-up capability. I changed to what is shown in the
last 3 PICS. I totally built this from parts I had in my bag of tricks.
Turns out it is much heavier than the VK system, but there is no give in
this system. Shown next are the separate components. |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
I had this
adjustable stem I bought a long time ago. It was intended for a mountain
bike, but because it was adjustable it was adaptable for my purpose.
Because it is adjustable, it is not the lightest component. I split it as
can be seen and put a carbon tube between. I then attached an aluminum
piece to the upper part with the aluminum part sliding inside the carbon. I
then got a RANS handlebar (cut down) to complete the system. Definitely not
as light as the VK system, but stiff and rigid and works for me. |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
Showing some
of the details of the built up bike, the first two PICS show the finished
handlebar/tiller system. The next shows the front boom. The two straps
that secure the front BB piece into the boom tube are robust and secure the
system without any rotation. They are also very light…..something I was not
able to accomplish with my bikes. The next PIC shows the front brake. A
Bacchetta-type pull down system is a necessity here. There is ample
clearance before interference of brake to front boom, enabling a tight turn
around…..something I am not able to do with my lowracers. All my upright
buddies know when I am riding my lowracers I have the turning capability of
an SR-71 (Blackbird Spy Plane) at cruise speed and altitude! The next PIC
shows the TerraCycle over/under idler. Truly a beautiful product! The last
two PICS show the rear stays attaching the upper seat to the main frame, and
the seat adjustment angle. More work is necessary here! It is not rigid
enough for me. My fix is to attach the two members to each other with round
carbon tubing. There is too much flexibility in the rear and I think
increasing the torsional stiffness in the rear end will help with the
rotational stiffness. I put miles on this set-up…..perhaps nearly not
enough, however. I was not comfortable sitting that high or what I
perceived as overall too much flexibility. I attributed this to a number of
factors: The boom was very long (I have an X-seam of 47 inches) and the fork
length (26 inches vs. 20) made the front end flex too much for me. Also the
rear was flexy (previously mentioned). Perhaps more time on the machine
would have fixed that, but I wanted to try something else. I surmised that
my time on a lowracer with a small front wheel was the ultimate in front end
rigidity (assuming the boom is also stiff). My next experiment was to
change out the front wheel to a 406 20 inch wheel and see how that works. |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
This change
made quite a difference. More like the lowracer bikes that I am used to.
The front end stiffened up by quite a bit. I think making my fixes to the
rear end will increase the performance also. One of the good things is that
it is a smaller bike which more lends itself to transporting…..perhaps a SUV
rather than a minivan, as I must do with all my past and present lowracers.
Another pro is the turning radius. I can now do a 180 on a two lane road.
I am not, however, up to the speed I can attain on my lowracers, hopefully
that will change with time on the machine. I think that has to do with the
seat /BB height. On my lowracers that number is about 7 inches. On this
set-up it is approximately 3 inches. Perhaps that difference will not allow
me to generate the same force on the cranks. I am still trying different
seat angles. On my lowracers the angle is about 25-26 degrees. On this
machine it is 31-32 degrees. I do, however, have the capability to change
it. Obviously more experimentation needed.
My decision is
to keep experimenting, but my main ride continues to be my XPort. I have
approximately 6,000 miles on it and 5,200 were in 06. It is as stiff a bike
I ever had. The front end does not rotate a bit even with hard mashing. It
is not as comfortable as my Baron Clone, but that is because of the front
wheel drive system, and the fork rake. The weight of the VKHi shown here is
approximately 21 pounds. I am, however, using a ROTOR system which weighs 1
pound more than a light weight crank. Also, I am using a tiller/handlebar
system that is much heavier than the Velokraft supplied system. It is very
conceivable that this bike with all-around light components could come in at
19 pounds. |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
Shown in this
series is my Baron Clone frame with fork. My records indicate that I have
22-24,000 miles on it. There appeared a series of cracks and fractures
which led me to consider retiring it. It is, however, the most comfortable
bike I ever had, so I am re-considering. Let’s talk about the failure
mode. My analysis is as follows: I made 3 frames, one I gave to a senior
engineering student for a thesis. The other was imperfect and is shown in
this PIC. The third became my Baron Clone. If you look at the carbon frame,
you can see (hopefully it will show in the photo) a migration of the
expanding foam (that was used in the core) into the not fully cured epoxy
resin. It shows as a slight discoloration of the black with what seems like
an amber color. It is my analysis that this weakened the carbon shell.
Also, the cracks appear where filler (not strong, only for show) was applied
over the carbon shell (because of the construction process) and did not add
to the overall strength. These fractures do not appear in my XPort after
6,000 miles because it was made by the “shell” process, a process that I
still recommend. The bike (BC) is comfortable because the fork rake is like
68 degrees, rather than the 74 degrees used in my XPort, the latter being
more difficult to hold a straight line, and perhaps because it is not as
stiff. On my BC I would alternate arms and “hug” my back with one (elbow
facing forward) while steering with the other, creating a windshield. This
method I believe was perfected by the Euro boys…..some great riders and
innovators. I hesitate to do this on my XPort! For these reasons I plan
as my next bike venture (along with my home projects, my Benz projects and
whatever projects) a rebuilding of my present BC. Confucius say “Man who
have project…..cannot die!” I guess I live by that!
Having said
all that, my plan is to start with the existing frame and strip it,
re-structure the failure and attachment points and cover it with carbon
sleeves. I will bond the nose piece to the boom and also the seat to the
frame for added rigidity. The last four PICS show the molds made for the
BC. The form started with a male two part plug, from which was then made a
female too part female shell. The last PIC shows the lid that was made
because I filled the halves with expanding foam (again not recommended).
Since I do not want to start a new frame from scratch, I am willing to offer
these mold to the HPV community for building purposes…..no charge…..except
you pay the freight! The only stipulation is that if there are numerous
takers, you share with the next. Please contact me if interested for
particulars. I also have a final frame jig for the final assembly for the
assembly of the rear stays. One step at a time! I was going to destroy
these molds for lack of storage, but perhaps they can be used for whatever
purpose. Next Time! |
|